Approaches to Teaching Beowulf - Tolkien's View

  • PDF
  • Print
  • E-mail
Article Index
Approaches to Teaching Beowulf
All Pages
Tolkien’s view:

One theory is that the Beowulf poet was a Christian monk who, perhaps, wrote the poem down at a time when Christianity was making inroads into his previously pagan civilization.  That is why, throughout the poem, there are elements of Christianity (Beowulf as a Christ figure, sacrificing himself for his people, and elements of paganism such as the dragon and fate as a determining factor.  Along this line of thinking we have Grendel descended from Cain, the twelve disciples who follow Beowulf into the second fight but, like Christ’s disciples, abandon him at the critical moment.  On the pagan side of the ledger, we have the concept of endoedoeg, (final day), the notion that fate is the overhanging cloud above us all.  We die because it is our day to die.

Quick thoughts:

  • The theme of Christianity is tinged with the despair of paganism: "that man, each man and all men, and all their works shall die."
  • The Beowulf poet is concerned with the romantic past--heathen, noble and hopeless.
  • The "wages of heroism is death." Tolkien
  • In the final conflict Beowulf possesses what he does not possess fighting Grendel and grendel’s mother - -wisdom—
  • fame is fleeting --Beowulf is acutely aware of his mortality, and by extension his insignificance.
  • The poem, according to Tolkien, is not a narrative--it is a balance of youth and age—first achievement and final death.  The poem does not begin with young Beowulf and narrate his entire life.  The fifty years he is king is barely discussed at all.  The poem is a contrast between young Beowulf, physically strong and full of fortitude, and old Beowulf, physically weakened but relying more on sapientia.
  • Tolkien contends that the poem is not an epic - -it is a heroic elegiac poem. The purpose of its historical allusions, which other critics say is the real meat of the work, is to give a sense of perspective of antiquity, "with a greater and yet darker antiquity behind...Great heroes should show themselves capable of dealing also with the ordinary things of life.' This is why there is brief mention of Beowulf's accomplishment as king.
  • Tolkien disagrees with the disappointment other scholars have found in Beowulf. They seek history and find discrepancies: they expect narrative and find contrast, a lack of orderly time sequence. Tolkien thinks we should view the poem as a work of art - -not as history or epic.  It was designed to extol heroism.



0 #251 Jonathon 2018-03-14 08:46
for just a high quote harry potter epub
download: they inspire work exactly the same way
fifty shades of grey epub
download: if promotion has low traffic pride
and prejudice epub: add your text divergent
veronica roth epub: who will provide the machines 50 shades of grey infinite jest epub (Jonathon: (Jacquelyn: could
start offering tools the
way of kings epub:
0 #250 BrodieChief 2018-03-13 15:12
I have checked your blog and i've found
some duplicate content, that's why you don't rank
high in google, but there is a tool that can help you to create 100% unique articles, search for:
boorfe's tips unlimited content
0 #249 2018-03-01 08:37
Dochter van 13 kreeg met 12 jaar zo'n fiets.
0 #248 seks met buurvrouw 2018-02-22 11:56
15% van de vrouwen gaat vreemd, dat is niet mis.
0 #247 seks daten 2018-02-21 07:45
Maar het laat wel zien dat hij je leuk vindt.
0 #246 2018-02-20 18:52
Je maakt elkaar beide gek stop daarmee en ga ervoor.
0 #245 serie tv samedi soir 2018-02-20 14:22
Des séries TV et des films personnalisés pour vous.
0 #244 gratis datentransfer 2018-02-20 00:03
En de leukste vrouwen bevinden zich in het wild?
0 #243 2018-02-19 07:24
Sex en porno : Lekker je buurmeisje neuken en filmen.
0 #242 João Enzo Gabriel 2018-02-15 03:28
37) noção de marketing é uma filosofia empresarial.
0 #241 João Lucas 2018-02-14 06:49
Críticos desejam sustentar dois sistemas paralelos.
0 #240 Pedro Isaac 2018-02-11 11:00
esboçado é traço preto feito próximo aos cílios.
0 #239 Rosaria 2018-02-08 18:20
Helⅼo tо aⅼl, it's genuinely a fastidious fߋr
me to visit tһis website, іt includes precious Ӏnformation.

My homepage :: bad credit rating loan (Rosaria:
0 #238 Leopoldo 2018-02-08 08:20
Terrific worҝ! This iѕ the kind of іnformation tһat are supposed tо be shared aroսnd tһe web.
Shame on tһe seek ebgines foor no llnger positioning tһis publish upper!
Ϲome on oѵеr and consult witһ my site . Thanks =)

Feel free tο surf to my site; Biến tần Mitsubishi ϜR-A740[Leopoldo:]
0 #237 Trinidad 2018-02-06 13:21
Hellߋ there I am so thrilled I found your webpage, I really fߋund you by
accident, whіle I waas browsing on Bing f᧐r sometһing eⅼse,
Anyhoww Ι am һere now and would just like tߋ
say kudos for a remarkable post and a all гound thrilling
blog (І alѕo love tһе theme/design), I ⅾon’t hаve tіme
too read thгough it all ɑt the moment but Ι hаve book-marked it аnd ɑlso included
your RSS feeds, so ѡhen I have time I wіll Ƅe back tto гead a lot mߋгe, Pleɑse dо keep
up the superb b.

Here іs my page: local relocation - Trinidad: -
0 #236 Maria Isabelly 2018-02-05 15:42
Não importa quanto tempo você passe nele, é impraticável cansar
do We♥It, particularmente porque, enquanto você não quiser heartar
zero, pode voltar nos hearts antigos ver como nossos gostos mudaram e também tudo mas.
0 #235 Emanuelly 2018-01-28 14:03
Seja sutil, sem furar jogo antes da hora.

Add comment

Security code

A Class Act--Teaching for Smarties


  • Een relatief nieuwe online activiteit is vreemdgaa...
  • I have checked your site and i have found some dup...
  • research paper research paper research papers rese...
  • for just a high quote harry potter epub download: ...
  • I have checked your site and i have found some dup...